The story under this square

A stereo shop robbery became a night of torture and murder

You stand a few streets from the storefront where a routine burglary turned into one of Utah's worst mass murders.
Last reviewed 20 September 2026 · A two-minute read · 1850–1988
The short answer

On April 22, 1974, gunmen took hostages at the Hi-Fi Shop 314 metres from this ground near the United States Post Office and Courthouse in Ogden, forcing them to drink Drano and shooting them in the basement, killing Carol Naisbitt, Stanley Walker and Sherry Michelle Ansley; Cortney Naisbitt and Orren Walker survived. Dale Selby Pierre and William Andrews were later executed for the killings.

A stereo shop robbery became a night of torture and murder — Ogden
West view of the historic Ben Lomond Hotel , in Ogden , Utah , United States . — 2008 · Ntsimp · Public domain
April 22, 1974

A stereo shop robbery ended in three basement murders

Several men walked into the Hi-Fi Shop on Washington Boulevard shortly before closing time and began taking hostages. Two employees, Stanley Walker and Sherry Michelle Ansley, were bound in the basement. A 16-year-old named Cortney Naisbitt walked in later to thank Walker for a parking favor and was tied up alongside them. Then Stanley's father, Orren Walker, came looking for his son. Carol Naisbitt arrived soon after, searching for hers. Five people sat bound in that basement by nightfall.

The airman Dale Selby Pierre ordered Orren Walker to make the hostages drink Drano, telling them it was vodka laced with sleeping pills. Walker refused and was left face-down on the floor. Pierre and William Andrews forced the drain cleaner on the others instead. It blistered their mouths and throats within seconds.

He shot Carol and Cortney Naisbitt in the backs of their heads. Carol died. Cortney survived. He killed Stanley Walker, missed Orren twice, then raped Ansley in a basement corner and shot her dead. When Orren Walker was found still breathing, Pierre and Andrews tried to strangle him with wire, then drove a ballpoint pen through his ear. He lived. Pierre and Andrews were later convicted and executed for the killings.

Pierre grew angry that the deaths were taking too long and too loud, so he began shooting.
1850

A settler's stray shot killed a Shoshone chief

A settler named Urban Stewart fired at random into his own cornfield in 1850. The shot killed Terikee, chief of the Weber band of Shoshone, on ground that would become Ogden. The killing was not planned. It came out of an ordinary chore on an ordinary piece of land, and it set off retaliatory violence between settlers and Native people across the valley for years afterward.

1854 to 1855

Settlers built a walled fort out of fear

Terikee's death left Ogden's scattered farm families afraid of reprisal. They abandoned their separate homesteads and built Bingham Fort, a walled compound about half a mile west of Five Points, its perimeter wall standing nine feet high around a defensive mound. It was fear, built in timber and earth, a direct answer to a killing that had started as an accident.

1907 to now

A commercial building has stood on this lot since 1907

The building at 298 24th Street, the lot beneath your own feet, went up in 1907 as a commercial structure. Weber County's assessor records it now at nearly 61,000 square feet on a lot just under an acre and a half. It has stood through the entire span of this history, from the fort-building years still fresh in local memory when it was framed, through the decades of Ogden growing into a rail town, into the present day, changing hands and uses as commercial property does, without ever leaving this exact ground.

2026

Two inmates died in custody at the county jail

Two inmates have died in custody at the Weber County Jail in the same year: one found unresponsive during an early morning check on April 6, and a second who died after a medical event on September 1. Both were ruled the result of medical crises rather than violence inflicted by another hand. The jail sits on the same ground that has, across a century and a half, kept turning routine confinement and ordinary errands into something fatal.

The storefront and the jail cell are gone from view now, but the ground under this corner has a long habit of turning the ordinary into the fatal.

Open this place in Strata

Every person, building and event in this story opens into its own dig in the app — and it will dig the ground you are standing on instead, wherever that is.

Open this place in Strata Universal Link · falls back to the App Store

Where this is

41.223°N 111.978°W TILE ≈ 1.2 × 0.6 KM
Place
United States Post Office and Courthouse (Ogden, Utah)
Town
Ogden
Country
United States
Tile
≈1.2 × 0.6 km (geohash6)
Last reviewed
20 September 2026

The layers, in order

Sourced records, high and medium confidence. Era background is marked as such.
Early modern
1850
In 1850 a settler named Urban Stewart fired at random into his own cornfield and killed Terikee, chief of the Weber band of Shoshones, setting off a cycle of retaliatory violence around Ogden.
1854-1855
After Terikee's killing, fearful Ogden settlers abandoned their scattered farms and in 1854-55 built Bingham Fort, ringed by a wall nine feet high, near present-day Five Points.
Modern
1907
The commercial building recorded on this exact lot at 298 24th Street went up in 1907, and county records still carry it as a commercial parcel of nearly 61,000 square feet.
April 22, 1974
Just before closing time on April 22, 1974, several men walked into the Hi-Fi Shop 314 meters from here and began taking hostages at gunpoint.
Wikipedia: Hi-Fi murders · record, high
April 22, 1974
Dale Selby Pierre ordered Orren Walker, a 43-year-old father who had come looking for his son, to make the other hostages drink Drano; Walker refused and was bound instead.
Wikipedia: Hi-Fi murders · record, high
April 22, 1974
Cortney Naisbitt, 16, was taken hostage after stopping by only to thank an employee for a parking favor, and was shot in the back of the head but survived.
Wikipedia: Hi-Fi murders · record, high
April 22, 1974
Carol Naisbitt, Stanley Walker, and Sherry Michelle Ansley were shot dead in the shop's basement after hours of torture, and Ansley was raped before she was killed.
Wikipedia: Hi-Fi murders · record, high
after 1974
Dale Selby Pierre and William Andrews were convicted of murder and aggravated robbery and later executed; a third man, Keith Roberts, who waited outside, was convicted only of robbery.
Wikipedia: Hi-Fi murders · record, high

Questions about this place

Answered in one sentence, then in full above
What happened at the Hi-Fi Shop in Ogden?
On April 22, 1974, several men took hostages at gunpoint inside the Hi-Fi Shop, forced them to drink Drano in the basement, and then shot them; Carol Naisbitt, Stanley Walker, and Sherry Michelle Ansley were killed, while Cortney Naisbitt and Orren Walker survived.
Who was convicted of the Hi-Fi murders?
Dale Selby Pierre and William Andrews were convicted of murder and aggravated robbery and later executed; a third man, Keith Roberts, who waited outside, was convicted only of robbery.
What was here before the Hi-Fi Shop killings?
The ground around Ogden had earlier been the site of a settler's stray gunshot in 1850, which killed Terikee, chief of the Weber band of Shoshone, and led local families to abandon scattered farms and build the walled Bingham Fort in 1854-55.
When was the building at 298 24th Street built?
The commercial building on that lot went up in 1907 and is still recorded by Weber County's assessor as a commercial parcel of nearly 61,000 square feet.
What happened at the Weber County Jail in 2026?
Two inmates died in custody in the same year: one found unresponsive during an early morning check on April 6, and a second who died after a medical event on September 1, both ruled the result of medical crises.

Where this came from

1
Wikipedia: Hi-Fi murders — Gunmen take hostages at the Hi-Fi Shop
2
Ogden City Information Packet — A chief shot in his cornfield
3
Utah county assessor via UGRC parcel layer — The lot beneath you goes up in 1907

Dug nearby

The night the drain cleaner didn't kill fast enough
Helms Apartments, Ogden
1 km
The night a stereo shop errand became a massacre
Ogden, Ogden
2 km
The junction that became a city, then a base's shadow
196 East North Lakeview Drive, Clearfield
12 km